This Is Disclosure
Cheat sheet · Teachers and coaches

Cheat sheet for teachers and coaches.

Kids learn how people treat each other from how you treat the one who can do the least for you.

Not every hardship is a test, and nothing here is graded.

A woodcut of a teacher kneeling beside a small child sitting apart from a circle of other children, offering a hand while the circle begins to turn toward them.
  1. Notice who nobody picks.
    Teams, partners, lunch tables. Quietly arrange it so no one is left standing there. and make it the routine for everyone, not a rescue.
    Say"I'll pair you up today,"
  2. Praise the effort and the kindness, by name.
    or "You made room for him, and I saw it." Be specific so they know what to do again.
    Say"You stayed with that problem when it got hard,"
  3. Treat a mistake as normal, in front of everyone.
    When a student gets it wrong, thank them for trying and fix the problem, not the person. Do the same with your own mistakes.
    Say"Good attempt. Let's see where it went sideways."
  4. Keep the small rules fair.
    Same grace period, same turn, same tone for the star and the kid who struggles. Kids track fairness closely, and they learn it from you.
  5. Take the private word.
    For most corrections, speak quietly, at their level, away from the group.
    Say"Can I talk with you for a second? I want to understand what happened."
  6. Apologize when you are wrong.
    Short, plain, no excuses. Repair teaches more than perfection.
    Say"I blamed you before I checked. That wasn't fair, and I'm sorry."
  7. Let them help each other.
    Give the kid who gets it a chance to explain, and the kid who doesn't a chance to ask a peer. Teach them to disagree well.
    Say"Tell me what you heard them say before you answer."

The evidence behind this sheet

Large reviews link warm, trusting teacher-student relationships with more student engagement, and some trials suggest that how feedback is framed can matter. Programs and mindset messages tend to show modest average effects that vary by context.

The influence of affective teacher-student relationships on students' school engagement and achievement: a meta-analytic approachAcross 99 studies from preschool through high school, positive and negative teacher-student relationships showed medium-to-large associations with school engagement and small-to-medium associations with achievement, with some weakening after correcting for methodological bias.review · Review of Educational Research (via Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam research portal)Breaking the Cycle of Mistrust: Wise Interventions to Provide Critical Feedback Across the Racial DivideIn randomized field experiments with 7th graders, critical feedback paired with a statement of high standards and belief in the student's ability made students more likely to revise an essay and improved final drafts, with generally stronger effects among African American students.study · Journal of Experimental Psychology: General (PDF via Stanford SPARQ)The impact of enhancing students' social and emotional learning: a meta-analysis of school-based universal interventionsAcross 213 school-based programs involving about 270,000 students, participants improved on social-emotional skills, attitudes, behavior and academic performance compared with controls, including an 11-percentile-point achievement gain.review · Child Development (via PubMed)To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-AnalysesIn a meta-analysis of 43 intervention effects (N = 57,155) the authors called the overall effects of mind-set interventions on achievement weak, though students of low socioeconomic status or at academic risk might benefit.skeptical · Psychological ScienceInfluence of Sports Activities on Prosocial Behavior of Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Literature ReviewA review of 27 interventional studies concluded that sports activities improve prosocial behavior in children and adolescents, with different sports affecting it differently.review · International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health (via PubMed Central)Mandatory Reporting of Child Abuse and NeglectThis State Statutes Series publication (current through May 2023) summarizes state laws on which professionals must report suspected abuse or neglect and the standards for making a report, and points readers to state-by-state summaries.official · Child Welfare Information Gateway, U.S. Children's Bureau
Where the evidence is thin. Most teacher-student findings are correlational, and the Yeager trials were with 7th graders in specific settings. The mindset and social-emotional results are average effects that vary a lot by school and program, and the sports review covers organized programs, not any one coaching habit. This sheet's specific moves (a private word, an apology to a student, who gets picked) are not tested one by one, and direct evidence on public versus private reprimands is thin. Reporting laws differ by state and country, so check yours and your organization's policy.
If you only do one thing this week
Find the kid nobody picks, learn one true thing about them, and say it to them privately.

Stay curious about the hard kid. Ask "What's going on?" before "What's wrong with you?" But curiosity does not replace the rules: follow your school or league's safeguarding policy, never keep a child's disclosure secret, and report suspected abuse or neglect as the law in your state or country requires. If you are a mandated reporter, you report on reasonable suspicion, not proof. Do not investigate it yourself.

This is practical, not religious. I think what you show with your choices is what counts. Share it freely.

thisisdisclosure.com/cheat-sheets · A free message, nothing to buy or join · Share freely